Best Bakerys in Indianapolis (2026 Rankings)

Rene's Bakery Inc stands out as Indianapolis' premier destination for artisanal baked goods. They are renowned for their meticulously crafted custom cakes that serve as edible masterpieces for any occasion. Beyond cakes, their selection of pastries and breads offers a delightful taste of handcrafted quality.

A beloved Indianapolis institution, Long's Bakery is famous for its iconic donuts that draw crowds daily. Their no-frills approach focuses on delivering consistently delicious treats that have been a local favorite for years. Expect a lively atmosphere and a wide array of classic donut flavors.

This iteration of Long's Bakery continues the legacy of providing comforting and familiar baked goods to the community. It's a go-to spot for a quick, satisfying treat, offering the same quality that has made the name synonymous with great donuts. Enjoy the simple pleasure of a perfectly made classic.

Taylor's Bakery has been a cornerstone of the Indianapolis community, offering a wide range of classic baked goods with a focus on quality and tradition. Their specialty is creating beautiful and delicious cakes for all of life's celebrations. Visitors also appreciate their selection of cookies and pastries, perfect for any craving.

Boyden's Southside Bakery is a cherished local spot known for its hearty, homestyle baked goods. They excel in creating classic cakes, pies, and cookies that evoke a sense of comfort and nostalgia. It's the perfect place to find a delicious treat made with care and a personal touch.

Leviathan Bakehouse offers a contemporary take on baked goods, focusing on high-quality ingredients and inventive flavors. They are particularly celebrated for their exceptional sourdough breads and unique pastry creations. This spot is ideal for those seeking a sophisticated and delicious bakery experience.

Amelia's Fletcher Place is a charming bakery celebrated for its artisanal breads and delightful pastries. Their commitment to traditional baking methods shines through in every product, from crusty loaves to sweet treats. It's a warm and inviting space perfect for enjoying a coffee and a freshly baked item.

Rise 'n Roll Bakery in Greenwood is a bright and cheerful spot famous for its delectable cinnamon rolls and donuts. This bakery offers a wide array of sweet treats that are perfect for starting your day or enjoying as an afternoon pick-me-up. Their friendly service and delicious offerings make it a must-visit.

Hart Bakery & Gifts combines delicious baked goods with a unique gift shop experience, creating a delightful destination. They offer a tempting selection of cookies, cakes, and pastries made with a homemade touch. It's a wonderful place to find a sweet treat and a unique present.

Kim’s Kakery, Bakery & Café is a vibrant establishment offering a creative array of baked goods and a friendly café atmosphere. They specialize in beautifully decorated custom cakes that are as delicious as they are visually stunning. Visitors can also enjoy a variety of pastries, cookies, and light fare in a welcoming setting.

* This business has a high rating but fewer reviews than average. We include it as a "Hidden Gem" worth exploring.