Best Dessert Shops in Fort Wayne (2026 Rankings)

Pufferbelly Ice Cream is a beloved local institution known for its handcrafted ice cream made with high-quality ingredients. Their commitment to unique flavors and classic favorites has earned them top honors. It's the perfect place to cool down on a warm day or indulge in a sweet treat any time.

This charming cafe might be small, but its impact on Fort Wayne's dessert lovers is mighty. Udder Upp Cafe specializes in creative and generously portioned milkshakes that are as visually appealing as they are delicious. Don't let its modest review count fool you; this place is a true hidden gem for milkshake aficionados.

* This business has a high rating but fewer reviews than average. We include it as a "Hidden Gem" worth exploring.

Hoshi Hoshi offers a sophisticated dessert experience with a focus on beautifully crafted treats. Their innovative approach to flavors and presentation makes each visit a culinary adventure. Expect meticulously made pastries and desserts that are almost too pretty to eat.

Moo-Over is a go-to spot for classic ice cream cones and sundaes, perfect for a casual outing. They offer a wide array of flavors and toppings to customize your perfect frozen treat. It's the ideal destination for families and anyone seeking a straightforward, delicious ice cream experience.

Specializing in delightful crispy cones, this shop offers a unique twist on the traditional ice cream experience. Their signature cones provide a satisfying crunch that perfectly complements the creamy fillings. It's a popular spot for those looking for a novel and tasty dessert.

Oh Five Scoop Shop is a bright and cheerful place dedicated to serving up delicious scoops of ice cream. They pride themselves on a friendly atmosphere and a commitment to quality ingredients. You can find a delightful selection of flavors that cater to both traditionalists and adventurous eaters.

Chillz Delights offers a refreshing array of frozen treats and sweet concoctions. Their menu is designed to provide a cool and satisfying experience, perfect for a pick-me-up. This spot is known for its delightful flavors and welcoming service.

Just Cream Ice Cream Boutique elevates the ice cream experience with its artisanal approach and sophisticated flavors. They use premium ingredients to create rich, creamy, and memorable desserts. This boutique is a must-visit for those who appreciate the finer things in frozen treats.

A long-standing favorite, Zesto Ice Cream offers a taste of nostalgia with its classic frozen treats. They are known for their soft-serve cones, sundaes, and shakes, served in a no-frills, friendly environment. It’s a reliable spot for a satisfying and familiar dessert experience.

DeBrand Fine Chocolates is the ultimate destination for exquisite chocolate creations and gourmet desserts. Their meticulously crafted chocolates, truffles, and confections are perfect for gifting or personal indulgence. Step into their elegant shop for a truly decadent experience.