Best Gastropubs in Indianapolis (2026 Rankings)

Mayfair Taproom is a beloved neighborhood gastropub renowned for its extensive and thoughtfully curated selection of craft beers on tap. Their commitment to quality extends to their delicious menu, featuring elevated pub fare designed to pair perfectly with their brews. It's the go-to spot for a relaxed evening with friends, offering a consistently excellent experience.

Twenty Tap boasts an impressive array of rotating craft beers, making it a pilgrimage site for hop aficionados. Beyond the beer, their menu shines with inventive gastropub classics and a focus on quality ingredients. This spot is celebrated for its energetic atmosphere and its ability to satisfy both beer connoisseurs and discerning diners.

Don't let the modest review count fool you; None The Wiser Taproom is a gem for those in the know, offering a carefully selected range of craft beers. The taproom provides a warm and inviting atmosphere, complemented by a menu that punches above its weight with flavorful dishes. It's the perfect place to discover new brews and enjoy a laid-back meal.

* This business has a high rating but fewer reviews than average. We include it as a "Hidden Gem" worth exploring.

Kuma's Corner is famous for its heavy metal-themed ambiance and its legendary burgers, each named after a rock band. This Indianapolis staple offers a robust beer selection that perfectly complements their indulgent menu. It's a high-energy destination where great food, killer tunes, and a lively crowd converge.

Union 50 offers a sophisticated gastropub experience with a focus on craft cocktails and an inspired menu that blends classic and contemporary flavors. The stylish interior and lively atmosphere make it a popular choice for date nights and evenings out. Enjoy their curated selection of beers alongside innovative dishes in a chic setting.

Located conveniently by the Monon Trail, Fire by the Monon is a vibrant spot known for its expansive outdoor patio and lively social scene. They offer a diverse menu of American favorites and a solid rotation of craft beers, making it a perfect summer hangout. Enjoy the energetic atmosphere and delicious food in this popular neighborhood gathering place.

Taxman CityWay brings a unique Belgian-inspired beer experience to the heart of Indianapolis, featuring an extensive list of their own brews alongside carefully chosen guest taps. Their menu offers elevated pub fare with a sophisticated twist, perfect for pairing with their distinctive beers. This sleek establishment provides a refined yet relaxed atmosphere for enjoying quality food and drink.

The Red Key Tavern is a timeless Indianapolis institution, celebrated for its no-frills approach and classic tavern feel. It's a beloved spot for its reliable pub grub and a welcoming atmosphere that keeps locals coming back. While not strictly a gastropub, its enduring popularity and community vibe make it a must-visit for casual dining.

Housed in a historic building, the G.C. Murphy Building offers a unique dining experience with a focus on craft beer and creative American cuisine. The ambiance blends historical charm with a modern gastropub sensibility, making it a distinctive destination. Patrons appreciate the thoughtful menu and the impressive selection of brews available.

Yard House is known for its massive selection of draft beers, featuring hundreds of choices from around the globe. The extensive menu offers a wide variety of American fusion dishes, ensuring something for everyone. Its large, energetic space makes it ideal for groups and sports viewing, combining a lively bar atmosphere with a full-service restaurant experience.