Best Ice Cream Shops in Buffalo (2026 Rankings)

Experience a taste of Sicily right here in Buffalo with their authentic Italian gelato. Each scoop is crafted with passion, offering a rich and creamy experience. It's the perfect escape for a sweet, European-inspired treat.

Step into a world of sweet possibilities at Sweet World Worldwide, where creativity meets classic flavors. Their extensive menu offers something for every palate, ensuring a delightful visit. It's a destination for pure, unadulterated joy in every cone.

Discover the exquisite flavors of Maplewood Gelato, a true hidden gem for discerning dessert lovers. Their small-batch approach ensures unparalleled freshness and quality in every bite. This charming spot is perfect for those seeking a more refined and intimate ice cream experience.

* This business has a high rating but fewer reviews than average. We include it as a "Hidden Gem" worth exploring.

Fran-Ceil Custard is a beloved Buffalo institution, known for its rich and smooth frozen custard. With a long history and a loyal following, it's a go-to spot for a timeless treat. Enjoy a taste of tradition that has been satisfying cravings for years.

PJ COOLS Ice Cream Shoppe is a vibrant spot dedicated to delivering smiles with every scoop. They offer a wide array of flavors and toppings, making it a fun destination for all ages. Come for the ice cream, stay for the cheerful atmosphere.

At Rosie's Handcrafted Ice Cream, expect innovative flavors and high-quality ingredients in every artisanal creation. Their commitment to small-batch production shines through in the exceptional taste. It's the perfect place to explore unique dessert combinations.

Lake Effect Ice Cream has earned its reputation as a go-to destination for ice cream enthusiasts. Their generous portions and diverse flavor selection keep customers coming back for more. It's a lively spot that captures the spirit of Buffalo's sweet tooth.

Sweet Jenny's offers a delightful combination of decadent chocolates and delicious ice cream, creating a true paradise for dessert lovers. Their extensive offerings cater to every craving, from rich chocolate creations to refreshing ice cream flavors. It's the ultimate stop for a sweet indulgence.

2 Scoops Ice Cream is a local favorite, providing a wide variety of classic and creative ice cream flavors. The cheerful atmosphere makes it a welcoming spot for families and friends to gather. Enjoy a generous serving of happiness in every cone.

Halleez lives up to its name as the ultimate sweet spot, offering a delightful array of frozen treats and confections. Their commitment to quality and customer satisfaction is evident in every delicious bite. This is the perfect destination to satisfy any sweet craving.