Best Ice Cream Shops in Cincinnati (2026 Rankings)

Experience a true taste of Mexico at La Super Michoacana, a beloved spot for authentic paletas and ice cream. Their vibrant flavors, often made with fresh fruit, offer a refreshing and unique frozen dessert experience. This local gem is a must-visit for anyone seeking a truly special treat.

Indulge in the smooth, rich textures of authentic Italian gelato at Golden Gelato. They pride themselves on using high-quality ingredients to craft a wide array of classic and seasonal flavors. Each spoonful is a testament to their dedication to the art of gelato making.

Nestled by the train tracks, the Sugar Shack offers a whimsical escape with its delightful ice cream creations. This charming spot serves up generous scoops and creative sundaes that are sure to satisfy any sweet tooth. It's the perfect place to enjoy a treat while soaking in the unique atmosphere.

The Colonel's Creamery is a local favorite for classic ice cream flavors and friendly service. They offer a nostalgic experience with generous portions and a wide selection of toppings. It's the ideal spot for a family outing or a simple, delicious treat.

A Cincinnati institution, Aglamesis Bro's has been delighting customers with their handcrafted ice cream and exquisite chocolates for generations. Step into a charmingly old-fashioned parlor and choose from a tempting array of flavors. It's a place where sweet memories are made.

The Dipper is a go-to spot for delicious, creamy ice cream served with a smile. They offer a diverse menu of flavors and fun toppings, making it easy to customize your perfect dessert. Enjoy a relaxed atmosphere perfect for a casual treat.

Saddle up for a unique ice cream experience at Cowboy Cones, where a touch of the Wild West meets sweet indulgence. They serve up hearty portions of ice cream with creative toppings and themed treats. This spot offers a fun and memorable dessert adventure.

The Lil Goodie Shoppe is a cherished neighborhood spot known for its classic ice cream parlor feel and extensive menu. They offer a wide variety of flavors, sundaes, and other sweet treats that appeal to all ages. It's a place that feels like home, serving up comfort in every scoop.

Hello Honey offers a contemporary take on ice cream with unique flavor combinations and beautiful presentation. Their artisanal approach ensures a high-quality and memorable tasting experience. Discover inventive desserts that are as visually appealing as they are delicious.

Another beloved location from the Aglamesis family, this spot continues the tradition of excellence in ice cream and chocolate. Enjoy their time-honored recipes and charming atmosphere for a truly classic treat. It's a perfect destination for a nostalgic sweet escape.