Best Ice Cream Shops in Newark (2026 Rankings)

This is the ultimate destination for customizable ice cream sandwiches. Choose from a variety of freshly baked cookies and decadent ice cream flavors to create your perfect treat. Don't forget to add a topping for the ultimate indulgence.

Known for its rich, dairy-based ice cream and vibrant vegan options, Van Leeuwen offers a sophisticated sweet experience. Their inventive flavor combinations are a testament to their commitment to quality ingredients. It's a must-visit for those seeking a premium scoop.

Scoop Theory delights with its unique and rotating selection of handcrafted ice cream flavors. Each batch is made with passion, offering a delightful surprise with every visit. Prepare to discover your new favorite flavor here.

This location of Van Leeuwen continues the brand's tradition of exceptional ice cream, catering to both dairy lovers and vegans alike. Expect a delightful array of classic and adventurous flavors that are sure to satisfy. It's a perfect spot for a sweet escape.

Experience ice cream like never before with ZRolls' unique rolled ice cream creations. Watch as your chosen ingredients are artfully transformed into delicious frozen rolls right before your eyes. It's a fun and tasty spectacle for all ages.

Stack Creamery offers a delightful array of ice cream creations, from loaded cones to towering sundaes. Their generous portions and creative toppings make for a truly satisfying dessert experience. It's the perfect place to celebrate a sweet craving.

This artisanal shop focuses on high-quality, handcrafted ice cream with unique flavor profiles. Using premium ingredients, Honey & Hive delivers a sophisticated and memorable tasting experience. Discover their inspired seasonal offerings.

Sweet Sofi is a delightful spot for authentic Italian gelato and refreshing sorbetto. Their commitment to small-batch production ensures the freshest and most vibrant flavors. It’s a true taste of Italy right here in Newark.

* This business has a high rating but fewer reviews than average. We include it as a "Hidden Gem" worth exploring.

A long-standing Newark institution, Torico Ice Cream has been serving up smiles for generations. They boast a wide variety of classic and beloved flavors, made with a dedication to tradition. This is the go-to spot for a timeless ice cream experience.

Nasto's offers a delightful journey into the past with its 'Old World Desserts' and classic ice cream flavors. This beloved spot has been a community staple for years, serving up generous scoops and nostalgic treats. Enjoy a taste of history with every spoonful.