Best Ice Cream Shops in Oklahoma City (2026 Rankings)

Scoop House and Bakery stands out with its impressive five-star rating, a testament to their dedication to quality and flavor. Beyond their exceptional ice cream, they also offer a tempting array of baked goods, making it a one-stop shop for sweet cravings. This beloved spot is clearly a local favorite, consistently delighting customers with its creative offerings and welcoming atmosphere.

Boom Town Creamery is a celebrated name in Oklahoma City, known for its high ratings and extensive customer base. They specialize in small-batch ice cream, ensuring unique and high-quality flavors that keep customers coming back for more. The creamery's popularity is evident in its substantial number of reviews, marking it as a go-to spot for discerning ice cream lovers.

Tizo's Pops & Ice Cream offers a refreshing twist with its popular frozen treats, earning a strong following and impressive reviews. While known for its ice cream, the mention of 'Pops' suggests a delightful range of frozen novelty options. This establishment is a vibrant choice for those seeking delicious and cooling desserts in the heart of the city.

This specific location of Boom Town Creamery focuses on its renowned small-batch ice cream, offering a more intimate experience. Despite its smaller review count compared to its sibling, the high rating indicates a consistent quality and dedication to unique flavor profiles. It's a perfect spot to discover inventive ice cream creations in a charming setting.

Roxy's Ice Cream Social is a long-standing favorite, boasting a large number of positive reviews that speak to its enduring appeal. Known for its classic ice cream parlor feel, Roxy's offers a delightful social experience alongside its delicious frozen desserts. It's the kind of place that brings a smile to your face with its nostalgic charm and consistently satisfying treats.

Mojo Ice Cream and Treats is a delightful find, offering a high rating with a modest number of reviews, suggesting a hidden gem quality. This establishment likely provides a unique and memorable ice cream experience for those who discover it. It's a promising spot for those seeking something special and less mainstream.

* This business has a high rating but fewer reviews than average. We include it as a "Hidden Gem" worth exploring.

Freezing Cow OKC is a popular spot that draws a significant crowd, evidenced by its high review count and solid rating. Known for its creamy offerings, it provides a refreshing escape from the Oklahoma heat. This establishment is a reliable choice for a satisfying ice cream experience with a modern flair.

Another iteration of Boom Town Creamery's small-batch concept, this shop focuses on crafting unique, high-quality ice cream flavors. While it has a smaller review count, its strong rating suggests a dedicated following appreciates its artisanal approach. This location is ideal for experiencing the creative spirit of Boom Town in a more focused setting.

Neveria La Azteca is a community staple, recognized for its extensive customer base and authentic frozen treats. With over a thousand reviews, it's clear this establishment serves up beloved flavors that resonate deeply with locals. It's the go-to place for traditional Mexican paletas and ice cream, offering a taste of cultural richness.

The Gelato Caffe brings a touch of Italian sophistication to Oklahoma City, offering authentic gelato and a charming cafe atmosphere. Its respectable rating and number of reviews indicate a well-loved spot for those seeking a premium frozen dessert experience. This caffe is perfect for a refined treat, whether you're enjoying a scoop of rich gelato or a specialty coffee.