Best Ice Cream Shops in Toledo (2026 Rankings)

This beloved spot is a true gem for ice cream lovers in Toledo. With a perfect blend of high ratings and a smaller, more intimate setting, it offers a unique and memorable experience. Come discover why it's a local secret worth celebrating.

* This business has a high rating but fewer reviews than average. We include it as a "Hidden Gem" worth exploring.

A long-standing favorite, Mr. Freeze delivers a classic ice cream parlor experience that generations have come to love. Their extensive menu and high volume of satisfied customers speak to their consistent quality. It's the perfect place for a family outing or a sweet treat after a long day.

Embrace the charm of Mr. G's Barn, a local institution renowned for its vast selection and community feel. This spot has earned its reputation through years of serving up delicious frozen delights to happy customers. Prepare for a taste of tradition with every scoop.

Another testament to the Mr. Freeze legacy, this location continues to impress with its wide array of ice cream flavors and dedicated following. Enjoy the same beloved treats that have made the brand a Toledo staple. It's a reliable choice for a consistently great ice cream experience.

Handel's Homemade Ice Cream is a must-visit for those seeking expertly crafted frozen desserts. Their commitment to quality ingredients and innovative flavors shines through in every serving. This popular spot offers a vibrant atmosphere perfect for enjoying a scoop (or two).

Step back in time with Fritzie Freeze Inc., a classic drive-in style ice cream shop that exudes retro charm. They offer a delightful range of frozen treats perfect for a quick and tasty indulgence. It's the ideal spot to grab a cone and enjoy a taste of nostalgia.

Freeze Daddy's offers a contemporary take on classic ice cream parlor delights. With a solid reputation and a variety of tempting options, it's a great place to cool down. Enjoy their creative flavors in a relaxed and friendly environment.

This branch of Handel's continues the brand's tradition of excellence in homemade ice cream. Expect a wide selection of flavors crafted with care and served with a smile. It's a go-to destination for quality frozen desserts in a bustling setting.

Chitter Chatter Ice Cream is a charming spot known for its unique name and delicious offerings. This neighborhood favorite provides a warm and inviting atmosphere for enjoying a variety of ice cream flavors. Come for the treats, stay for the friendly conversation.

Hannah's Soft Serve is your classic destination for creamy, dreamy soft serve ice cream. This straightforward shop focuses on delivering pure, unadulterated soft serve joy. It's the perfect uncomplicated stop for a satisfying frozen treat.