Best Italian Restaurants in Buffalo (2026 Rankings)

Da Nando stands out as Buffalo's premier Italian destination, consistently earning top marks for its exquisite dishes and refined atmosphere. Patrons rave about the authentic flavors and impeccable service that make every meal a memorable occasion. It's the perfect spot for a special night out or when you simply crave the best.

Forno Napoli brings the vibrant tastes of Naples to Buffalo with its authentic pizzas and classic Italian fare. The bustling atmosphere makes it a great spot for enjoying delicious food in a friendly setting. Expect a true taste of Italy in every bite.

Daniela offers a warm and inviting experience, serving up traditional Italian dishes with a homemade touch. This beloved restaurant is known for its comforting flavors and friendly service that makes you feel right at home. It's a go-to for genuine Italian comfort food.

The Barrel Restaurant is a Buffalo institution, celebrated for its extensive menu of Italian classics and generous portions. With a long-standing reputation, it offers a dining experience that feels both familiar and satisfying. This is the place for those seeking a hearty and traditional Italian meal.

Ilio DiPaolo's has been a cornerstone of Buffalo's Italian dining landscape for generations, offering a taste of old-world charm and classic recipes. The warm, family-oriented atmosphere complements its hearty and flavorful dishes perfectly. It's an ideal choice for family gatherings and celebrating special moments.

Mulberry Italian Ristorante is a beloved spot known for its generous servings of classic Italian-American comfort food. The energetic ambiance and dedication to traditional recipes make it a favorite among locals. Come here for a satisfying meal that feels like a true taste of home.

Dario's Family Cucina offers a delightful escape into authentic Italian home cooking, tucked away for those in the know. Its intimate setting and dedication to traditional family recipes create a truly special dining experience. Discover a hidden gem where passion for Italian food shines through.

* This business has a high rating but fewer reviews than average. We include it as a "Hidden Gem" worth exploring.

Rizzo's House of Parm lives up to its name, serving up fantastic versions of everyone's favorite Italian-American comfort food. The lively atmosphere and focus on dishes like chicken parmesan make it a popular choice for a fun and delicious meal. It's the go-to spot for satisfying those classic cravings.

Amici Ristorante provides a welcoming atmosphere perfect for enjoying a variety of Italian culinary delights. Known for its friendly service and well-prepared dishes, it's a reliable choice for a satisfying Italian meal. This neighborhood favorite offers a taste of Italy with a touch of Buffalo hospitality.

Bella Ciao offers a modern take on Italian dining, blending contemporary style with classic flavors. The chic ambiance and carefully crafted menu make it a sophisticated choice for an Italian night out. Enjoy a refined dining experience that celebrates the best of Italian cuisine.