Best Italian Restaurants in Gilbert (2026 Rankings)

This beloved establishment is a true Gilbert gem, consistently earning top marks for its authentic Italian cuisine and warm, inviting atmosphere. From delicious pizzas to hearty pasta dishes, Vito's offers a taste of Italy that keeps locals coming back for more. It's the perfect spot for a casual family dinner or a celebratory meal.

Floridino's is a popular choice for those seeking delicious pizzas and classic pasta dishes in a vibrant setting. Their extensive menu offers something for everyone, making it a go-to for families and friends. Enjoy generous portions and a friendly dining experience that feels like home.

With a massive number of reviews, RigaTony's has cemented its reputation as a Gilbert favorite for authentic Italian fare. They serve up generous portions of classic dishes in a warm and welcoming environment. It's the ideal place to experience traditional Italian cooking with a focus on flavor and quality.

The Sicilian Butcher offers a unique dining experience with its focus on house-made meatballs and fresh pasta. This trendy spot buzzes with energy, making it perfect for a night out with friends. Enjoy their creative dishes and lively atmosphere that sets them apart.

Spinato's is a long-standing institution known for its delicious pizzas and family-friendly atmosphere. This comfortable kitchen serves up classic Italian-American favorites that appeal to all ages. It's the perfect place for a relaxed meal with loved ones, offering consistent quality and generous servings.

Picazzo's redefines Italian dining with a focus on healthy and fresh ingredients, offering gluten-free and vegan options alongside traditional favorites. The atmosphere is chic and modern, appealing to those who want delicious food that aligns with a healthier lifestyle. Enjoy innovative dishes in a stylish setting.

While technically in South Tempe, Postino is a popular spot for its unique bruschetta boards and extensive wine list, offering a sophisticated yet relaxed Italian-inspired experience. The vibrant atmosphere makes it ideal for social gatherings and casual dates. It's a great place to unwind and enjoy delicious small plates.

Oregano's is known for its fun, eclectic atmosphere and hearty Italian-American comfort food. Their signature deep-dish pizzas and pasta dishes are crowd-pleasers, served in a lively and quirky setting. It's a go-to for a casual and satisfying meal with a unique local flair.

Stone & Vine offers a modern take on Italian dining with a focus on fresh, seasonal ingredients and a stylish urban ambiance. Their menu features artisanal pizzas, fresh pasta, and a curated selection of wines. It’s an excellent choice for a sophisticated dinner or a special occasion.

This second listing for Vito's highlights its consistent quality and appeal as a neighborhood favorite for Italian cuisine. It offers a comfortable and unpretentious dining experience, perfect for enjoying familiar Italian dishes. Expect the same great taste and friendly service that makes this restaurant a local treasure.