Best Italian Restaurants in Jersey City (2026 Rankings)

Osteria La Baia stands out as the top choice for Italian cuisine in Jersey City. This restaurant consistently delights diners with its exquisite dishes and charming atmosphere. It's the perfect place for a special occasion or a refined everyday meal.

Del Porto Italian Restaurant is a beloved establishment known for its robust flavors and generous portions. Experience the heartiness of traditional Italian cooking in a welcoming setting. It's a go-to spot for those craving classic comfort food.

While located in SoHo, its reputation influences Jersey City's Italian food lovers. La Pecora Bianca offers a sophisticated take on Italian classics with a focus on fresh, seasonal ingredients. The ambiance is perfect for a stylish night out.

Osteria Nonnino brings a taste of Nonna's kitchen to Jersey City with its authentic Italian fare. This restaurant prides itself on time-honored recipes and a warm, familial atmosphere. Enjoy a genuine taste of Italy crafted with love and tradition.

As the name suggests, Pasta de Pasta is a haven for pasta lovers in Jersey City. They serve up a delightful array of pasta dishes, each prepared with care and authentic Italian ingredients. It's the ideal spot for a satisfying and flavorful pasta experience.

Isabelle's Osteria is a true hidden gem offering an exceptional Italian dining experience. This cozy spot serves up beautifully crafted dishes that highlight the best of Italian cuisine. It's the perfect place to discover a new favorite Italian restaurant.

* This business has a high rating but fewer reviews than average. We include it as a "Hidden Gem" worth exploring.

Tony's Di Napoli is renowned for its vibrant atmosphere and generous family-style Italian portions. This lively restaurant is perfect for group gatherings and sharing hearty, classic dishes. Come hungry and ready to enjoy a true taste of Italian celebration.

Casa D'Angelo New York offers a classic Italian dining experience with a focus on traditional recipes and a warm ambiance. This restaurant is a staple for those seeking authentic flavors and a comfortable setting. Enjoy a taste of Italian heritage in every dish.

Sicily Osteria transports diners to the beautiful island of Sicily with its authentic regional cuisine. Explore the unique flavors and culinary traditions of Sicily in a rustic and inviting setting. It's an ideal destination for an adventurous Italian meal.

Osteria Barocca provides a sophisticated yet approachable Italian dining experience. This restaurant blends modern culinary techniques with classic Italian flavors for a memorable meal. Enjoy a refined atmosphere perfect for date nights or business dinners.