Best Italian Restaurants in Louisville (2026 Rankings)

While not strictly Italian, Classico Takeout Empanadas offers an incredible explosion of flavor that rivals the best comfort food. Their expertly crafted empanadas are a testament to quality ingredients and culinary passion. This spot is a must-try for those seeking a unique and satisfying bite.

SAM'S CHICAGO GRILL brings the bold flavors of Chicago to Louisville with their renowned pizzas and grilled specialties. Expect generous portions and a vibrant atmosphere perfect for group gatherings. It's a go-to for a hearty, satisfying meal that doesn't compromise on taste.

Bellissimo offers an elevated Italian dining experience with a focus on traditional recipes and a sophisticated ambiance. Their extensive menu features classic pasta dishes, fresh seafood, and delectable desserts. It's the ideal destination for a special occasion or a refined evening out.

Experience the authentic taste of New York-style pizza at New York Pizza Company, known for its perfectly crisp crusts and generous toppings. This eatery is a local favorite for its straightforward approach to delicious pizza. Grab a slice or a whole pie for a classic, satisfying meal.

Craft House Pizza - Germantown stands out with its inventive pizza creations and a welcoming, laid-back atmosphere. They focus on quality ingredients and unique flavor combinations that go beyond the traditional. This spot is perfect for a casual night out with friends looking for a delicious twist on pizza.

* This business has a high rating but fewer reviews than average. We include it as a "Hidden Gem" worth exploring.

Volare Italian Ristorante is a Louisville institution, celebrated for its authentic Northern Italian cuisine and impeccable service. The elegant dining room provides a perfect backdrop for their rich, flavorful dishes. It remains a top choice for those seeking a classic and memorable Italian dining experience.

Perso offers a contemporary take on Italian dining, blending traditional flavors with modern culinary techniques. The stylish interior complements their innovative menu, featuring unique pasta dishes and expertly prepared entrees. It's a fantastic choice for a sophisticated and flavorful meal.

Arno Pizza is a beloved neighborhood spot renowned for its delicious, no-fuss pizzas and welcoming atmosphere. They consistently deliver satisfying pies with fresh ingredients and a classic taste. This is the perfect place for a relaxed family dinner or a casual lunch.

The Black Italian offers a distinctive culinary experience with its creative fusion of Italian flavors and unexpected twists. Their menu is designed to surprise and delight, featuring bold dishes in a stylish setting. This is an exciting option for adventurous eaters seeking something beyond the ordinary.

* This business has a high rating but fewer reviews than average. We include it as a "Hidden Gem" worth exploring.

Pizza Jones is celebrated for its artisanal approach to pizza, using high-quality ingredients and creative flavor combinations. The cozy atmosphere makes it a perfect spot for enjoying a delicious, handcrafted pie. They offer a delightful experience for pizza lovers seeking quality and creativity.