Best Italian Restaurants in Madison (2026 Rankings)

A beloved Madison institution, Fraboni's offers an unparalleled selection of authentic Italian specialties and deli classics. Their commitment to quality ingredients shines through in every sandwich, pasta dish, and imported good. It's the perfect spot for a quick, delicious lunch or to stock up on gourmet Italian groceries.

Novanta brings a sophisticated yet approachable Italian dining experience to Madison. Expect expertly crafted pasta dishes and flavorful entrees in a stylish setting. It's an ideal destination for date nights or special occasions where refined Italian cuisine is on the menu.

Osteria Novella is a charming spot that punches above its weight in authentic Italian flavors. This intimate osteria focuses on expertly prepared pasta and traditional dishes in a warm, inviting atmosphere. It's a perfect choice for those seeking a more personal and memorable dining experience.

* This business has a high rating but fewer reviews than average. We include it as a "Hidden Gem" worth exploring.

Bar Corallini offers a vibrant and social Italian dining experience, perfect for gathering with friends. Their menu features a delightful array of small plates, pizzas, and classic Italian entrees. Enjoy the bustling atmosphere and expertly crafted cocktails alongside your meal.

Gino's Italian Deli is a long-standing favorite for those craving hearty, traditional Italian sandwiches and prepared foods. This no-frills spot prioritizes flavor and generous portions, making it a go-to for a satisfying and authentic meal. It's the quintessential neighborhood deli experience.

While known for pizza, Sugar River Pizza Co. in Verona also offers a range of Italian-inspired dishes in a welcoming environment. Their extensive menu caters to diverse tastes, making it a great option for families and groups. Enjoy their commitment to quality ingredients and friendly service.

Cento presents a contemporary take on Italian cuisine with a focus on fresh, seasonal ingredients. The sophisticated ambiance makes it suitable for both business dinners and elegant evenings out. Explore their innovative menu that pays homage to Italian culinary traditions.

Pizza Brutta is celebrated for its authentic Neapolitan-style pizzas, baked to perfection in a wood-fired oven. Beyond their signature pizzas, they offer a selection of Italian appetizers and entrees. The lively atmosphere and dedication to quality ingredients make it a standout.

Lombardino's Restaurant offers a refined Italian dining experience with a long-standing reputation for excellence. Their menu features classic Italian dishes prepared with care and served in an elegant setting. It's a perfect choice for celebrating milestones or enjoying a sophisticated meal.

Zafferano Ristorante provides an intimate and romantic setting for enjoying authentic Italian flavors. Specializing in traditional recipes, they offer a curated menu of pasta, seafood, and meat dishes. This cozy restaurant is ideal for a quiet, romantic dinner.