Best Italian Restaurants in Milwaukee (2026 Rankings)

Santino's Little Italy is a beloved Milwaukee institution, celebrated for its traditional Italian fare and warm, family-friendly atmosphere. Patrons rave about their generous portions and the feeling of stepping into a true Italian home. It's the perfect spot for a comforting meal that honors generations of culinary heritage.

Ca'Lucchenzo offers a refined Italian dining experience with a focus on fresh, seasonal ingredients and artfully prepared dishes. This intimate restaurant provides a sophisticated yet comfortable setting, perfect for a romantic evening or a special celebration. Expect impeccable service and a menu that highlights the best of Italian gastronomy.

Safina presents a contemporary take on Italian cuisine, blending traditional techniques with innovative flavor combinations. The stylish ambiance makes it an ideal destination for those seeking a chic dining experience. Discover a menu that is both familiar and exciting, showcasing the versatility of Italian cooking.

Stella Van Buren delivers a sophisticated Italian-American experience in a beautifully designed space. Known for its expertly crafted cocktails and a menu featuring both classic and modern Italian dishes, it's a popular spot for a vibrant night out. The restaurant buzzes with energy, making it perfect for lively dinners and celebrations.

Tenuta's Italian Restaurant is a long-standing favorite in Milwaukee, renowned for its hearty, homestyle Italian cooking and generous portions. This casual eatery offers a welcoming atmosphere where families can gather and enjoy classic dishes. It's the go-to place for a comforting and satisfying Italian meal that feels like home.

San Giorgio Pizzeria Napoletana is dedicated to serving authentic Neapolitan-style pizzas, cooked in a traditional wood-fired oven. The focus here is on simple, high-quality ingredients that shine through in every bite. Enjoy a true taste of Naples in a relaxed and inviting setting.

Nadi Plates offers a unique culinary journey, blending Italian influences with other global flavors in a charming and intimate setting. This gem is perfect for adventurous eaters seeking innovative dishes prepared with passion. Experience a delightful surprise with every plate served.

* This business has a high rating but fewer reviews than average. We include it as a "Hidden Gem" worth exploring.

Balistreri's Italian-American Ristorante has been a Milwaukee staple for decades, serving up classic Italian-American comfort food in a lively, no-frills environment. This beloved spot is known for its generous portions, friendly service, and a consistent, satisfying dining experience. It's the quintessential neighborhood Italian restaurant where everyone feels welcome.

Ann's Italian Restaurant provides a taste of traditional Italian cooking with a focus on comforting, homemade dishes. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, reminiscent of a classic family trattoria. Diners appreciate the authentic flavors and the feeling of being part of the family when they visit.

Zarletti offers an upscale Italian dining experience in the heart of downtown Milwaukee, known for its refined atmosphere and expertly prepared dishes. The menu features a thoughtful selection of pastas, seafood, and meats, all crafted with high-quality ingredients. It's an ideal choice for a special occasion or a business dinner where ambiance and culinary excellence are paramount.