Best Italian Restaurants in Newark (2026 Rankings)

Consistently lauded as the top choice, Del Porto offers an unparalleled Italian dining experience. Expect sophisticated dishes crafted with the freshest ingredients, served in a refined atmosphere. It's the perfect spot for special occasions or a memorable night out.

A true hidden gem, Ferdi provides an intimate and authentic taste of Italy. This charming spot is perfect for those seeking genuine Italian hospitality and expertly prepared classic dishes. Discover a local favorite that punches above its weight in flavor and quality.

* This business has a high rating but fewer reviews than average. We include it as a "Hidden Gem" worth exploring.

Casa D'Angelo brings a taste of old-school New York Italian charm to Newark. With a vast number of reviews, it's clear this establishment is a beloved staple for classic Italian-American fare. Enjoy generous portions and a lively atmosphere that feels like a family gathering.

Step into Sofia's of Little Italy for a warm and inviting dining experience reminiscent of traditional Italian neighborhoods. This popular spot is known for its hearty portions and comforting, authentic recipes. It's a go-to for families and groups seeking a genuine taste of Italy.

Osteria Barocca offers a rustic and charming escape into Italian culinary traditions. This eatery focuses on authentic regional dishes, prepared with passion and served in a cozy setting. It's a perfect destination for those who appreciate the finer, more traditional aspects of Italian cooking.

Zia Maria Chelsea brings the heart of Italian home cooking to Newark with its authentic and welcoming atmosphere. The restaurant is celebrated for its commitment to traditional recipes and quality ingredients. Enjoy a genuine taste of Italy in a setting that feels both familiar and special.

Brooklyn Roots Italian offers a modern take on classic Italian cuisine, blending traditional flavors with contemporary culinary techniques. The restaurant prides itself on sourcing quality ingredients to create memorable dishes. Experience innovative Italian fare in a stylish and engaging environment.

Felice on Hudson provides a chic and vibrant dining experience with a focus on refined Italian cuisine. This establishment offers a sophisticated menu featuring expertly crafted dishes and an impressive wine list. It's an ideal choice for a stylish evening out with exceptional food and ambiance.

Amici Ristorante is a long-standing favorite, known for its warm atmosphere and classic Italian dishes. The restaurant consistently delivers satisfying meals that celebrate the richness of Italian culinary heritage. Gather with friends and family for a delightful dining experience that feels like coming home.

Il Corallo Trattoria offers an authentic and cozy slice of Italy right in Newark. This trattoria is dedicated to serving traditional Italian recipes with a focus on fresh, quality ingredients. Enjoy a relaxed meal in a setting that captures the essence of Italian dining.