Best Italian Restaurants in Pittsburgh (2026 Rankings)

Pane è Pronto, meaning 'bread is ready,' lives up to its name by serving fresh, delicious Italian classics. This spot is perfect for those seeking a genuine taste of Italy without the fuss. It's a true hidden gem that punches above its weight in flavor and charm.

* This business has a high rating but fewer reviews than average. We include it as a "Hidden Gem" worth exploring.

DiAnoia's Eatery is a beloved Pittsburgh establishment known for its extensive menu of traditional Italian dishes. With a lively atmosphere and a vast number of reviews, it's a consistent favorite for a reason. Enjoy everything from handmade pasta to classic entrees in a vibrant setting.

Located in the heart of Shadyside, Mercurio's offers a warm and inviting atmosphere for enjoying authentic Italian cuisine. Their menu features a delightful array of pasta, pizza, and other Italian specialties. It's a go-to spot for both casual weeknight dinners and special occasions.

Verona Village Inn brings a taste of classic Italian dining to its patrons with a menu full of comforting favorites. This restaurant has built a strong reputation for its quality food and welcoming service. It’s an ideal choice for a satisfying meal in a traditional setting.

LeoGreta offers a contemporary take on Italian dining, blending classic flavors with a stylish ambiance. The restaurant is celebrated for its creative dishes and sophisticated dining experience. It's a perfect destination for those looking for an elevated Italian meal.

Scoglio's USC is a popular local spot renowned for its delicious Italian offerings and friendly service. The menu is packed with traditional favorites, making it a reliable choice for a satisfying meal. Come for the food, stay for the comfortable atmosphere.

Cucina Vitale promises a vital taste of Italy with its carefully crafted menu and charming dining room. This restaurant focuses on fresh ingredients and authentic preparation methods. It's an excellent choice for a date night or a quiet dinner with loved ones.

Armstrong's Express provides a convenient and delicious way to enjoy Italian flavors on the go or in a relaxed setting. Known for its efficient service and tasty dishes, it's a great option for a quick lunch or a casual dinner. Experience satisfying Italian comfort food made easy.

Girasole offers a refined Italian dining experience with a focus on high-quality ingredients and classic recipes. The restaurant boasts a beautiful setting, perfect for enjoying a leisurely meal. Indulge in their expertly prepared pastas and entrees for a memorable culinary journey.

Piccolo Forno, meaning 'small oven,' specializes in authentic Neapolitan pizzas and other Italian delights cooked to perfection. The intimate setting and delicious wood-fired creations make it a popular choice for pizza lovers. Enjoy a taste of Naples right here in Pittsburgh.