Best Italian Restaurants in Riverside (2026 Rankings)

BellaMia Pasta stands out as the top choice for authentic Italian cuisine in Riverside. Their commitment to fresh ingredients and traditional recipes shines through in every dish. It's the perfect spot for a memorable dining experience.

A beloved local spot, D'Caesaro offers a fantastic combination of delicious pizzas and classic Italian fare. With a vast number of reviews, their popularity speaks for itself. Enjoy a vibrant atmosphere perfect for any gathering.

Experience the heartwarming taste of Italy at Mamma Mia, a restaurant known for its generous portions and authentic recipes. The high volume of satisfied customers highlights their consistent quality. This is a go-to for a true taste of Italian home cooking.

Con Amore Ristorante provides an elegant setting for enjoying exquisite Italian dishes. Their carefully crafted menu and attentive service create a delightful dining experience. It's an ideal destination for a romantic evening or a special celebration.

Mazzullis' Family Kitchen lives up to its name, offering a warm and inviting atmosphere with delicious, family-style Italian meals. The consistent high ratings reflect their dedication to quality and customer satisfaction. Come here for comforting dishes that feel like home.

Don't let the name fool you; The Outpost is a surprising haven for authentic Italian flavors in Riverside. This spot offers a unique dining experience with expertly prepared dishes. It's a hidden gem worth seeking out for its quality and charm.

* This business has a high rating but fewer reviews than average. We include it as a "Hidden Gem" worth exploring.

Mario's Place is a long-standing favorite for Italian dining, consistently drawing crowds with its robust menu. The sheer volume of reviews indicates a well-loved establishment with a loyal following. Enjoy a lively atmosphere and generous servings of Italian classics.

Capone's Pizza brings a touch of old-school charm to Riverside, serving up delicious pizzas and Italian favorites. Their substantial review count highlights a consistent ability to please diners. This spot is great for a casual meal with a fun, retro vibe.

Antone's Italian Eatery offers a genuine neighborhood dining experience with a focus on traditional Italian dishes. The positive feedback from hundreds of reviews points to a reliable and delicious choice. It's the perfect place for a relaxed meal with friends and family.

Joe's Italian is a highly-rated establishment known for its extensive menu and consistent quality. With a large number of reviews, it's a dependable choice for satisfying your Italian cravings. Enjoy a no-fuss meal in a relaxed and friendly setting.