Best Italian Restaurants in St. Petersburg (2026 Rankings)

Fusillo Pasta St. Pete is a culinary gem that truly shines with its dedication to authentic Italian pasta. Each dish is crafted with care, showcasing fresh ingredients and traditional techniques. It's the perfect spot for an intimate and memorable Italian dining experience.

* This business has a high rating but fewer reviews than average. We include it as a "Hidden Gem" worth exploring.

Pia's Trattoria offers a warm and inviting atmosphere reminiscent of a classic Italian home. Their extensive menu features a wide array of beloved Italian classics, prepared with passion and served with genuine hospitality. It's a long-standing favorite for a reason, providing a consistent and delightful dining experience.

Buona Ristorante provides an upscale yet comfortable setting for enjoying authentic Italian cuisine. From expertly prepared seafood to rich pasta dishes, the menu reflects a commitment to quality and flavor. This establishment is ideal for both special occasions and casual gourmet meals.

Jay Luigi brings a contemporary flair to traditional Italian dining with its stylish ambiance. The kitchen focuses on fresh, seasonal ingredients to create innovative takes on Italian favorites. Enjoy a vibrant meal in a sophisticated setting perfect for a night out.

Step into Original Flavor 1889 for a taste of Italian heritage and authentic flavors. This restaurant prides itself on serving time-honored recipes passed down through generations. Experience the true essence of Italian cooking in a friendly and familiar environment.

Noble Crust is renowned for its unique fusion of Southern comfort food with Italian influences. Their creative menu offers unexpected yet delicious combinations, served in a lively and modern space. It's a go-to spot for those seeking a bold and flavorful culinary adventure.

Tuttorosso Restaurant & Pizzeria offers a classic Italian experience with a focus on delicious pizzas and traditional dishes. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, making it perfect for family dinners and casual gatherings. Enjoy authentic flavors prepared with care and served with a smile.

Bocelli Modern Italian delivers a refined dining experience with its contemporary interpretation of Italian classics. The restaurant features an elegant setting, perfect for romantic evenings or sophisticated gatherings. Expect artfully presented dishes that are as beautiful as they are delicious.

Italian Touch lives up to its name by providing a genuinely authentic and comforting Italian dining experience. This restaurant excels in serving hearty, traditional dishes made with high-quality ingredients. It's a beloved local spot for those who appreciate classic Italian cooking.

Circo Italian Kitchen offers a vibrant and modern take on Italian cuisine in a lively setting. The menu is a celebration of fresh flavors and creative preparations, appealing to a diverse palate. Dine here for an energetic atmosphere and a memorable Italian meal.