Best Italian Restaurants in Tampa (2026 Rankings)

This beloved spot consistently earns top marks for its authentic Italian pizzas and generous pasta portions. The buzzing atmosphere makes it a perfect choice for a fun and delicious meal with friends or family. Expect a true taste of Italy right here in Tampa.

Pizzitalia's is a must-visit for pizza aficionados, serving up expertly crafted pies with fresh, quality ingredients. Their commitment to traditional Italian techniques shines through in every bite. It's a charming destination for a relaxed and flavorful dining experience.

Step into a piece of Tampa history at Casa Santo Stefano, a restaurant that beautifully blends Sicilian heritage with modern culinary excellence. The ambiance transports you to the heart of Italy, offering a sophisticated setting for exquisite dishes. Savor the rich flavors and timeless traditions served here.

OLIVIA offers a contemporary take on Italian dining, focusing on fresh ingredients and innovative preparations. The stylish decor and vibrant energy create an upscale yet approachable atmosphere. It's an ideal spot for those seeking a refined and memorable Italian meal.

This gem focuses on the elemental beauty of water and flour, crafting exceptional artisanal pizzas and pastas. Their dedication to simple, high-quality ingredients results in deeply satisfying flavors. Enjoy a rustic and authentic Italian culinary journey.

Bocelli Modern Italian redefines Italian cuisine with a sophisticated and contemporary approach. The elegant ambiance is perfect for a special occasion or a refined night out. Indulge in their expertly curated menu featuring both classic and inventive Italian dishes.

Jay Luigi is a delightful neighborhood spot serving up authentic Italian fare with a personal touch. Despite its smaller review count, the quality of food and intimate atmosphere have earned it a loyal following. It's a perfect place to discover delicious, home-style Italian cooking.

* This business has a high rating but fewer reviews than average. We include it as a "Hidden Gem" worth exploring.

Bella's Italian Cafe has been a Tampa staple for years, known for its consistently delicious classic Italian dishes and warm hospitality. The comfortable and inviting atmosphere makes it feel like a home away from home. It's a reliable choice for a satisfying Italian meal.

Noble Crust offers a unique fusion of Southern Italian flavors with a modern, trendy twist. Their creative menu and lively atmosphere make for an exciting dining experience. It’s a great spot to explore inventive dishes that pay homage to Italian culinary traditions.

GINO's Restaurant & Bar is a long-standing favorite for its hearty portions of traditional Italian-American cuisine. The relaxed, family-friendly environment makes it a go-to for casual dinners and gatherings. Enjoy classic flavors and a welcoming dining experience.