Best Mexican Restaurants in Buffalo (2026 Rankings)

This beloved taqueria stands out as Buffalo's top Mexican eatery, boasting an impressive number of reviews and a near-perfect rating. It's the go-to spot for those seeking genuine Mexican flavors and a lively, casual dining experience. Prepare for a delicious adventure that lives up to its top ranking.

Margaritas Mexican Cantina offers a vibrant atmosphere perfect for a fun night out, complemented by its extensive menu of classic Mexican dishes. With a strong following and high ratings, it's a reliable choice for delicious food and good times. Enjoy a lively setting that brings the spirit of Mexico to Buffalo.

Known for its playful name and equally delightful cuisine, No Way Jose is a local favorite that consistently delivers on taste and experience. This spot offers a relaxed environment where you can savor well-crafted Mexican favorites. It's a must-try for anyone exploring Buffalo's diverse culinary landscape.

La Divina Tacos is a highly-rated establishment that has garnered significant attention for its flavorful tacos and vibrant dishes. The high volume of reviews underscores its popularity among locals and visitors alike. Come experience a fresh take on Mexican street food in a stylish setting.

As the sister restaurant to La Divina Tacos, La Divina Dos continues the tradition of excellent Mexican cuisine with its own unique flair. It offers a slightly more intimate yet still energetic atmosphere, perfect for enjoying delicious food. This spot is a testament to the quality and popularity of the La Divina brand.

Cielito Lindo Taqueria provides an authentic taste of Mexico in a cozy and welcoming environment. It has earned a loyal following for its delicious, traditional dishes and friendly service. This taqueria is a hidden gem for those seeking genuine flavors without the fuss.

Macho Tacos and Burger offers a unique fusion, blending the bold flavors of Mexican street food with classic American burgers. This creative approach has made it a popular spot for those looking for something a little different. Enjoy a casual dining experience with a menu that packs a punch.

Senor Leon Mexican Cantina & Grill is a fantastic find for those seeking delicious Mexican fare with a warm ambiance. Despite fewer reviews than some others, its high rating and positive sentiment mark it as a true hidden gem. Experience authentic flavors and friendly service that make you feel right at home.

* This business has a high rating but fewer reviews than average. We include it as a "Hidden Gem" worth exploring.

Don Juan Mexican Restaurant in West Seneca is a long-standing favorite known for its extensive menu and consistent quality. This restaurant offers a comfortable, family-friendly atmosphere perfect for any occasion. It's a reliable choice for satisfying your cravings with a wide array of traditional Mexican dishes.

El Canelo provides a taste of authentic Mexican cooking with a focus on traditional recipes and fresh ingredients. The high number of reviews indicates a strong and dedicated customer base who appreciate its classic offerings. This spot is ideal for a relaxed meal featuring time-honored Mexican flavors.