Best Pizza Restaurants in Buffalo (2026 Rankings)


Top rated spots for Pizza Restaurant
How we rank these businesses
We use public Google Maps data. Businesses with fewer reviews but high ratings are marked asHidden Gemsto give new businesses a fair shot.
Buffalo's pizza scene is a passionate battleground, with local favorites vying for the top spot. From classic New York slices to artisanal creations, these pizzerias consistently deliver exceptional pies that keep Buffalonians coming back for more.
Bflo Pizza Bistro
Vibe: Cozy, CasualTL;DR: Rank #1 & Hidden Gem: A top-tier choice with a cozy atmosphere, perfect for a delightful pizza experience.
This beloved bistro has earned its top spot with consistently stellar reviews and a high rating. It offers a welcoming atmosphere where you can enjoy expertly crafted pizzas made with quality ingredients. A true neighborhood gem that delivers on flavor and experience.
* This business has a high rating but fewer reviews than average. We include it as a "Hidden Gem" worth exploring.
Forno Napoli Pizza & Italian Restaurant
Vibe: Authentic, LivelyExperience the authentic taste of Naples right here in Buffalo at Forno Napoli. Their extensive reviews speak to a dedication to traditional Italian pizza-making, with a vibrant atmosphere to match. This is the place for a genuine Neapolitan pizza experience.
Extra Extra Pizza
Vibe: Modern, TrendyExtra Extra Pizza lives up to its name by offering a pizza experience that goes above and beyond. With a modern approach and a solid base of positive reviews, they are known for creative toppings and a stylish setting. Expect a delicious and visually appealing pie.
Zahz Pizza
Vibe: Family-Friendly, CasualA long-standing favorite, Zahz Pizza offers a classic pizza experience that has garnered a massive following. Their high review count is a testament to their consistent quality and crowd-pleasing flavors. It's a reliable choice for a satisfying pizza night.
Jay's Artisan Pizzeria
Vibe: Artisanal, Upscale CasualJay's Artisan Pizzeria elevates the humble pizza with a focus on high-quality, artisanal ingredients and preparation. The substantial number of reviews highlights their dedication to crafting unique and delicious pizzas. This spot is perfect for those seeking a more refined pizza experience.
Olisi's New York Style
Vibe: Classic, No-FrillsFor a taste of true New York style pizza, Olisi's is a top contender in Buffalo. They are praised for their authentic crust, generous toppings, and classic approach to pizza. This is the go-to for a no-nonsense, delicious slice.
VinLouie's Pizzeria
Vibe: Neighborhood, WelcomingVinLouie's Pizzeria offers a warm and inviting atmosphere alongside their highly-rated pizzas. Their consistent quality and friendly service have earned them a loyal customer base. Itβs a great spot for enjoying a comforting and delicious pizza.
D'Agostino's Pizzeria Inc.
Vibe: Traditional, FamilyD'Agostino's Pizzeria Inc. is a classic choice for those craving traditional pizza flavors. With a solid rating and a good number of reviews, they are known for delivering consistent quality. This establishment offers a taste of familiar comfort in every slice.
Imperial Pizza - Abbott Road
Vibe: Bustling, Local FavoriteImperial Pizza on Abbott Road is a true Buffalo institution, boasting an impressive number of reviews. Their consistent popularity points to a reliable and delicious pizza that locals adore. It's a go-to spot for a satisfying and classic pizza experience.
Joe's New York Style Pizza
Vibe: Classic, Fast-PacedJoe's New York Style Pizza delivers the quintessential New York slice experience with a large and dedicated following. The sheer volume of reviews indicates a consistently well-loved pizza joint. It's the perfect spot for a quick, satisfying, and authentic slice.
Methodology
Rankings based on Google Maps customer sentiment.
Own a business in Buffalo?
See how you rank against your competitors and take control of your online reputation.