Best Pizza Restaurants in Buffalo (2026 Rankings)

This beloved bistro has earned its top spot with consistently stellar reviews and a high rating. It offers a welcoming atmosphere where you can enjoy expertly crafted pizzas made with quality ingredients. A true neighborhood gem that delivers on flavor and experience.

* This business has a high rating but fewer reviews than average. We include it as a "Hidden Gem" worth exploring.

Experience the authentic taste of Naples right here in Buffalo at Forno Napoli. Their extensive reviews speak to a dedication to traditional Italian pizza-making, with a vibrant atmosphere to match. This is the place for a genuine Neapolitan pizza experience.

Extra Extra Pizza lives up to its name by offering a pizza experience that goes above and beyond. With a modern approach and a solid base of positive reviews, they are known for creative toppings and a stylish setting. Expect a delicious and visually appealing pie.

A long-standing favorite, Zahz Pizza offers a classic pizza experience that has garnered a massive following. Their high review count is a testament to their consistent quality and crowd-pleasing flavors. It's a reliable choice for a satisfying pizza night.

Jay's Artisan Pizzeria elevates the humble pizza with a focus on high-quality, artisanal ingredients and preparation. The substantial number of reviews highlights their dedication to crafting unique and delicious pizzas. This spot is perfect for those seeking a more refined pizza experience.

For a taste of true New York style pizza, Olisi's is a top contender in Buffalo. They are praised for their authentic crust, generous toppings, and classic approach to pizza. This is the go-to for a no-nonsense, delicious slice.

VinLouie's Pizzeria offers a warm and inviting atmosphere alongside their highly-rated pizzas. Their consistent quality and friendly service have earned them a loyal customer base. It’s a great spot for enjoying a comforting and delicious pizza.

D'Agostino's Pizzeria Inc. is a classic choice for those craving traditional pizza flavors. With a solid rating and a good number of reviews, they are known for delivering consistent quality. This establishment offers a taste of familiar comfort in every slice.

Imperial Pizza on Abbott Road is a true Buffalo institution, boasting an impressive number of reviews. Their consistent popularity points to a reliable and delicious pizza that locals adore. It's a go-to spot for a satisfying and classic pizza experience.

Joe's New York Style Pizza delivers the quintessential New York slice experience with a large and dedicated following. The sheer volume of reviews indicates a consistently well-loved pizza joint. It's the perfect spot for a quick, satisfying, and authentic slice.