Best Pizza Restaurants in Durham (2026 Rankings)

Timber Pizza Co. is a true standout, earning its top spot with exceptional wood-fired pizzas. Their commitment to quality ingredients shines through in every delicious bite. It's the perfect place for a relaxed meal with fantastic flavor.

* This business has a high rating but fewer reviews than average. We include it as a "Hidden Gem" worth exploring.

Hutchins Garage offers a unique dining experience in a renovated garage space, serving up creative and delicious pizzas. The bustling atmosphere makes it a popular spot for groups and dates alike. Enjoy their inventive toppings and solid crusts for a memorable meal.

Pizzeria Toro is a beloved Durham institution, renowned for its authentic Neapolitan-style pizzas baked in a blistering hot oven. The vibrant atmosphere and consistently excellent pies have garnered a loyal following. Come for the pizza, stay for the lively ambiance.

Bringing a taste of New York to Durham, Devil's NY Pizzeria & Restaurant serves up classic slices and pies with a satisfying chew. It's the go-to spot for those seeking a traditional pizzeria experience with generous portions. Expect a no-frills, delicious meal every time.

Emmy Squared Pizza offers a unique Detroit-style pizza experience with its signature square pies featuring a crispy, cheesy crust. Their creative topping combinations are a delightful departure from the ordinary. It's a great spot for a fun and flavorful pizza night.

Cugino Forno brings the rustic charm of an Italian bakery to Durham, specializing in authentic wood-fired pizzas. The high-heat oven creates a perfectly blistered crust with a delightfully chewy texture. It's an ideal choice for a genuine taste of Italy.

Randy's Pizza is a long-standing favorite in Durham, known for its reliable and delicious New York-style pizzas. They offer a wide variety of classic toppings and generous portion sizes. This is the place for a satisfying, no-fuss pizza fix.

Italian Pizzeria III has been serving Durham for years, offering a comforting and classic Italian pizza experience. Their dedication to traditional recipes and friendly service makes it a local staple. Enjoy a hearty slice or a full pie made with care.

Pie Pushers stands out with its unique pizza creations and a fun, rock-and-roll atmosphere. They offer a creative menu alongside classic options, ensuring something for everyone. It's a great spot to grab a slice with personality.

Sofia's Pizza provides a welcoming environment for enjoying classic pizzas with fresh ingredients. Their commitment to good food and friendly service makes it a reliable choice for families and friends. It's a solid spot for a satisfying and familiar pizza meal.