Best Pizza Restaurants in Indianapolis (2026 Rankings)


Top rated spots for Pizza Restaurant
How we rank these businesses
We use public Google Maps data. Businesses with fewer reviews but high ratings are marked asHidden Gemsto give new businesses a fair shot.
Indianapolis boasts a vibrant pizza scene, from classic slices to innovative pies. Whether you're craving a deep-dish delight or a New York-style thin crust, these local favorites are serving up some of the best pizza in the Circle City.
Pizzeria CamiΓ³n
Vibe: Casual & LivelyTL;DR: Authentic Neapolitan pies with a gourmet twist.
Pizzeria CamiΓ³n offers an authentic taste of Naples with their wood-fired pizzas, crafted using imported ingredients and traditional techniques. Their commitment to quality shines through in every flavorful bite, making it a must-visit for pizza purists. Enjoy a vibrant atmosphere that perfectly complements their exceptional Neapolitan-style pies.
Samβs Square Pie
Vibe: Neighborhood & CasualTL;DR: Detroit-style square pizzas with crispy edges.
Dive into the unique experience of Detroit-style pizza at Sam's Square Pie, known for its thick, focaccia-like crust and caramelized cheese edges. Each square is a delectable combination of chewy dough and savory toppings, baked to golden perfection. It's the ideal spot for a hearty and satisfying pizza feast in a relaxed setting.
Magoo's Pizza
Vibe: Family-Friendly & RetroTL;DR: Classic pizzas with generous toppings.
Magoo's Pizza is a beloved Indianapolis institution, serving up classic pizzas with a generous hand when it comes to toppings. Their recipes have been perfected over time, offering a comforting and familiar taste that keeps locals coming back. Expect a laid-back, family-friendly atmosphere perfect for a casual night out.
Last Chance Pizza
Vibe: Eclectic & FunkyTL;DR: Creative toppings on a thin, crispy crust.
For those seeking adventurous flavor combinations, Last Chance Pizza delivers a unique culinary experience with its inventive topping selections. Their pizzas are built on a foundation of perfectly crisp thin crusts, providing a delightful contrast to the bold ingredients. This spot is perfect for a fun and slightly unconventional pizza outing.
Brozinni Pizzeria
Vibe: Bustling & CasualTL;DR: New York-style slices and whole pies.
Brozinni Pizzeria brings the authentic taste of New York-style pizza to Indianapolis, offering massive, foldable slices and whole pies loaded with classic toppings. Their commitment to fresh ingredients and traditional preparation methods results in a consistently delicious experience. It's a go-to for a quick, satisfying slice or a hearty pie to share.
Bazbeaux Pizza
Vibe: Artsy & RelaxedTL;DR: Artisan pizzas with fresh, creative ingredients.
Bazbeaux Pizza is renowned for its artisan approach, crafting unique pizzas with an emphasis on fresh, high-quality ingredients and creative flavor pairings. Their diverse menu caters to a wide range of tastes, from classic combinations to more adventurous options. Enjoy a relaxed, artsy ambiance that complements their gourmet pizza creations.
Xtrordinary Pizza
Vibe: Modern & TrendyTL;DR: Gourmet pizzas with unique flavor profiles.
Xtrordinary Pizza lives up to its name by offering a menu filled with gourmet pizzas featuring unexpected and delightful flavor combinations. They focus on using premium ingredients to create truly memorable pies that stand out from the ordinary. The modern and trendy atmosphere makes it a great spot for a contemporary dining experience.
Greekβs Pizzeria 16th Street
Vibe: Casual & LocalTL;DR: Classic pepperoni and cheese, Indiana style.
Greek's Pizzeria on 16th Street is a local favorite, celebrated for its classic Indiana-style pizzas that are perfect for any occasion. They excel at delivering simple yet delicious pizzas, with a focus on well-balanced flavors and quality ingredients. This casual spot is a reliable choice for a satisfying and straightforward pizza experience.
Pizza Palace - Halal pizzas and Gyro
Vibe: Casual & DiverseTL;DR: Halal options and Mediterranean-inspired pizzas.
Pizza Palace offers a unique fusion of flavors, providing delicious halal pizzas alongside their popular gyros. Their menu is a testament to their commitment to catering to diverse palates with fresh, flavorful ingredients. Enjoy a casual dining experience that blends familiar pizza favorites with exciting Mediterranean influences.
Mia pizzaria
Vibe: Cozy & IntimateTL;DR: Authentic Italian pizzas in a cozy setting.
Mia Pizzaria transports diners to Italy with its authentic Italian pizzas, prepared with traditional methods and fresh, quality ingredients. The intimate and cozy atmosphere makes it an ideal destination for a romantic dinner or a quiet meal with friends. Savor the true taste of Italian pizza in a warm and inviting environment.
Methodology
Rankings based on Google Maps customer sentiment.
Own a business in Indianapolis?
See exactly how your reputation compares to these top 10 competitors.