Best Pizza Restaurants in Jacksonville (2026 Rankings)

Howieluv's has earned its top spot with a reputation for delivering mouthwatering pizzas alongside a solid selection of wings and subs. Their commitment to quality ingredients and generous portions makes it a go-to for a satisfying meal. Expect a laid-back atmosphere perfect for family dinners or casual get-togethers.

Experience the magic of true Neapolitan pizza at Emangeo's, where pies are expertly crafted in a scorching hot brick oven. This method imparts a delightful char and smoky flavor to their thin, chewy crusts. It's a must-try for pizza purists seeking an authentic taste of Italy.

* This business has a high rating but fewer reviews than average. We include it as a "Hidden Gem" worth exploring.

Pie95 Pizza stands out with its inventive topping combinations that go beyond the ordinary, all served on their distinctively delicious crust. They offer a fresh take on classic pizza, making each visit an opportunity to discover a new favorite. The lively atmosphere is perfect for a fun night out with friends.

A long-standing Jacksonville institution, Carmines Pie House is renowned for its commitment to traditional pizza-making and a welcoming environment. Their generous pies are perfect for sharing, and the consistently high volume of reviews speaks to their enduring popularity. This is the place for a hearty, no-fuss pizza experience.

Moon River Pizza offers a unique dining experience with its creatively named pizzas and charming, eclectic decor. They pride themselves on using fresh, high-quality ingredients to craft pies that are both flavorful and memorable. The relaxed and artistic ambiance makes it a delightful spot for a casual meal.

Pizza Point is a reliable neighborhood spot known for delivering consistently good pizza that hits the spot every time. They focus on classic flavors and well-executed recipes that have garnered a loyal following. It's a straightforward choice for a satisfying pizza fix.

Joseph's Pizza on Main St offers a taste of classic pizza done right, with a no-frills approach to quality and flavor. Their extensive menu ensures there's a pizza for every preference, from simple cheese to loaded specialty pies. This establishment is a testament to the enduring appeal of a well-made, traditional pizza.

Craving an authentic New York slice? Tony D's delivers with large, foldable pizzas featuring a perfect crust and classic toppings. Their dedication to replicating the New York pizza experience makes them a standout in Jacksonville. Enjoy a taste of the Big Apple without leaving town.

More than just a pizza place, Crispy's Springfield Gallery offers a unique fusion of delicious pizzas and an engaging art gallery atmosphere. Their pizzas are known for their creative flair and fresh ingredients, complementing the vibrant surroundings. It's an ideal spot for those seeking a meal combined with a cultural experience.

CUBAN PIZZERIA offers a distinctive twist on pizza, blending traditional Italian techniques with vibrant Cuban flavors. Their innovative approach results in unique flavor profiles that set them apart from the typical pizza joint. This spot is perfect for adventurous eaters looking for something truly different.

* This business has a high rating but fewer reviews than average. We include it as a "Hidden Gem" worth exploring.