Best Pizza Restaurants in Madison (2026 Rankings)

Novanta stands out as Madison's top pizza destination, consistently earning rave reviews for its exceptional quality and taste. Their dedication to authentic flavors and premium ingredients creates a truly memorable dining experience. It's the go-to spot for pizza aficionados seeking the absolute best.

A beloved Madison institution, Ian's on State Street is famous for its creative and often adventurous pizza toppings. This bustling location is perfect for students and locals alike looking for a fun and flavorful meal. Expect unique combinations and a vibrant atmosphere.

Sugar River Pizza Co. in Verona offers a delightful take on classic pizza with a commitment to fresh, quality ingredients. Their expansive menu caters to a wide range of tastes, making it a perfect spot for group outings or family dinners. Enjoy a satisfying meal in a welcoming environment.

Ian's Pizza on Frances Street brings its signature creative flair to another Madison neighborhood. This location offers the same inventive spirit and delicious pies that have made the brand a local favorite. It's a great spot for a casual bite with friends or family.

Pizza Brutta is renowned for its authentic Neapolitan-style pizzas, crafted with care in a wood-fired oven. The focus here is on simple, high-quality ingredients that shine through in every bite. It's an ideal choice for those who appreciate expertly made, traditional pizza.

Located within the historic Garver Feed Mill, this Ian's outpost offers its renowned pizzas in a unique and vibrant setting. Enjoy their creative topping combinations alongside the lively atmosphere of this popular Madison destination. It's a perfect blend of innovative pizza and a memorable location.

North Shore Pizza and Subs is a local gem offering delicious pizzas and hearty subs with a friendly neighborhood feel. Despite fewer reviews, its high rating suggests consistent quality and customer satisfaction. It's a fantastic choice for a no-frills, tasty meal.

* This business has a high rating but fewer reviews than average. We include it as a "Hidden Gem" worth exploring.

Jet's Pizza is known for its distinct Detroit-style square pizzas, featuring a thick, crispy crust and flavorful toppings. This chain offers a consistent and satisfying pizza experience for those who enjoy a deeper, richer slice. It's a dependable option for a hearty meal.

Lucille offers a unique dining experience with its focus on wood-fired pizzas and a lively, industrial-chic atmosphere. The extensive menu and popular bar make it a go-to spot for both food and drinks. It's a great place to gather with friends for a vibrant evening out.

Sugar River Pizza Co. provides a wide array of delicious pizzas made with fresh ingredients, appealing to a broad audience. This establishment is a solid choice for families and groups looking for a satisfying and enjoyable pizza experience. Their commitment to quality makes them a consistent favorite.