Best Pizza Restaurants in Newark (2026 Rankings)

Wahizza Pizzeria & Restaurant offers a unique Dominican and Italian culinary experience, making it a standout in Newark's pizza landscape. Their diverse menu caters to a wide range of tastes, ensuring a memorable meal for everyone. It's the perfect spot for those seeking a flavorful twist on traditional pizza.

Bella Pizza is a beloved establishment known for its consistently delicious pies and lively atmosphere. With a high volume of positive reviews, it's a reliable choice for a satisfying pizza experience. Come for the pizza, stay for the vibrant neighborhood feel.

Gravesend Pizza brings a taste of authentic New York-style pizza to Newark, offering a no-frills experience that lets the quality of the ingredients shine. This spot is a local favorite for its classic approach to pizza-making. It's a hidden gem for those who appreciate a true, no-nonsense slice.

* This business has a high rating but fewer reviews than average. We include it as a "Hidden Gem" worth exploring.

NY Pizza Suprema is a legendary name in the pizza world, drawing crowds with its classic New York slices. The sheer volume of reviews speaks to its enduring popularity and consistent quality. It's an essential stop for any serious pizza aficionado visiting the city.

Rubirosa is renowned for its thin-crust pizzas and vibrant, upscale atmosphere, making it a popular dining destination. They offer a creative take on classic pizzas with a focus on quality ingredients. It's the perfect place for a stylish night out with fantastic pizza.

Krispy Pizza brings the authentic Brooklyn pizza experience with its wide selection of delicious pies. This spot is a local favorite, known for its energetic vibe and consistently great pizza. Enjoy a taste of Brooklyn right here in Newark.

Dellarocco's specializes in brick oven pizzas, offering a delightful char and smoky flavor profile that sets their pies apart. The cozy atmosphere makes it a perfect spot for a relaxed meal with friends or family. Experience the artisanal difference of a true brick oven.

Mancini’s Wood-Fired Pizza promises a rustic and flavorful experience with pizzas cooked to perfection in a wood-fired oven. The inviting ambiance makes it a great place to gather and enjoy exceptional pizza. Their commitment to traditional cooking methods shines through in every bite.

Joe's Pizza is a quintessential New York-style pizzeria, famous for its no-nonsense approach and consistently excellent slices. It's a go-to spot for a quick, delicious, and authentic pizza experience. The long lines are a testament to its widespread appeal and quality.

Bleecker Street Pizza is a New York institution, celebrated for its classic slices and lively atmosphere. This pizzeria offers a quintessential urban pizza experience that keeps customers coming back. It's the perfect place to grab a reliable and delicious slice on the go.