Best Pizza Restaurants in St. Petersburg (2026 Rankings)

Experience artisanal pizza at its finest, crafted in a traditional wood-fired oven. Each pie boasts a perfectly blistered crust and high-quality, fresh toppings. This spot is a true gem for authentic Neapolitan-style pizza.

Known for its bold flavors and generous toppings, Killer Pizza lives up to its name. They offer a wide variety of specialty pizzas alongside classic favorites. It's a go-to spot for a satisfying and delicious pizza experience.

A long-standing favorite, Tobys delivers authentic Italian-American pizza with a taste of nostalgia. Their classic New York-style slices are a crowd-pleaser, made with time-honored recipes. This institution is perfect for a no-frills, delicious pizza fix.

Super Sardo's is a beloved local spot serving up generous portions of delicious pizza. Their commitment to fresh ingredients and classic preparation shines through in every bite. Expect a lively atmosphere and a consistently great pie.

This company offers a fresh take on pizza, combining creative toppings with a perfect crust. They focus on using locally sourced ingredients whenever possible, resulting in vibrant flavors. It's an excellent choice for those seeking unique and high-quality pizza.

Jay Luigi is known for its upscale yet approachable pizza experience. They offer a sophisticated menu with gourmet ingredients and inventive flavor combinations. Enjoy a stylish setting perfect for a date night or a fun outing with friends.

Step back in time with Original Flavor 1889, offering pizza with a taste of history. Their dedication to authentic recipes and quality ingredients creates a truly memorable dining experience. It's a charming spot for a comforting and delicious meal.

Charlie & Millie's is a community favorite, serving up hearty and delicious pizzas. Their consistent quality and friendly service make it a reliable choice for any pizza craving. It's the perfect place for a relaxed meal with family or friends.

This joint offers a modern and exciting pizza experience with a focus on fresh, flavorful ingredients. They are known for their creative specialty pies and a vibrant atmosphere. It's a great spot for those looking for a lively and delicious pizza outing.

Bringing a taste of the Big Apple to St. Petersburg, Manhattan City Pizza serves classic New York-style slices. Their thin crust and quality toppings are a perfect match for a quick and satisfying meal. Enjoy a slice of authentic city pizza here.