Best Pizza Restaurants in Toledo (2026 Rankings)

Saucey Slices Pizzeria is a true standout, consistently delighting diners with its exceptional pizza. Their commitment to fresh ingredients and unique flavor combinations has earned them the top spot in Toledo.

Experience the magic of stone-baked perfection at Mazzas. This beloved spot offers a delightful array of pizzas, each crafted with care and baked to golden-brown excellence.

Arturo's Pizza Kitchen is a local favorite, celebrated for its generous portions and authentic Italian flavors. Enjoy a wide selection of pizzas made with passion and served with a smile.

More than just a pizza place, The Village Idiot offers a unique dining experience with its lively atmosphere and diverse menu. Their pizzas are a testament to quality ingredients and creative culinary artistry.

Located just outside Toledo in Perrysburg, 5th Street Pub is renowned for its delicious pizzas and laid-back pub ambiance. It's the perfect spot to catch a game and enjoy a fantastic slice.

Hindsight Pizza lives up to its name by offering a well-thought-out menu that extends beyond just pizza. While their pizzas are a highlight, don't overlook their other savory offerings.

Home Slice Pizza delivers the comfort of a perfect slice with every order. This popular establishment offers a classic pizza experience that keeps customers coming back for more.

Pizza Cat brings a playful energy to the Toledo pizza scene with its distinctive name and delicious pies. Expect a fun dining experience coupled with consistently great pizza.

In Sylvania, J & G Pizza Palace is a go-to for reliable and tasty pizza. This local institution offers a traditional approach to pizza making, ensuring a satisfying meal.

Amie's Pizza Factory is a testament to the enduring appeal of well-made pizza. They pride themselves on crafting flavorful pizzas that have become a staple for many Toledo residents.