Best Steakhouses in Madison (2026 Rankings)

Housed in a beautifully restored train depot, The Harvey House offers a sophisticated dining experience. Their expertly prepared steaks, paired with an extensive wine list, make it a standout choice. Expect exceptional service in a setting that blends history with modern culinary excellence.

A long-standing Madison favorite, Tornado Steak House is known for its generous portions and classic American fare. This lively spot offers a true supper club atmosphere, perfect for a hearty meal. It's a go-to for those seeking a robust steak and a fun night out.

Nestled in a historic stone building, Quivey's Grove provides a unique and charming dining experience. Their menu features a selection of delicious steaks and traditional Wisconsin dishes. Enjoy a meal steeped in history and local flavor.

Delaney's Steak Seafood Wine lives up to its name, offering a well-rounded menu with a strong emphasis on quality steaks. The sophisticated yet approachable atmosphere makes it suitable for both special occasions and casual dinners. Their commitment to fine ingredients is evident in every dish.

While known for its impressive burger selection, Tipsy Cow also serves up excellent steaks in a vibrant, energetic setting. This popular gastropub is a lively spot for enjoying well-crafted dishes and a good drink. It's a great choice for a more modern and casual steak experience.

Toby's Supper Club offers a nostalgic journey back to classic dining with its vintage ambiance and hearty steaks. This establishment is beloved for its traditional supper club experience, complete with friendly service. It’s a place where comfort food and good times are always on the menu.

Johnny's Italian Steakhouse blends the best of Italian cuisine with classic steakhouse fare. Enjoy a sophisticated dining experience with a menu that features both premium steaks and beloved Italian dishes. The warm and inviting atmosphere makes it ideal for intimate dinners.

Johnny Delmonico's Steakhouse provides an upscale dining experience with a focus on prime steaks and seafood. The refined atmosphere and attentive service create a memorable meal. It's a perfect destination for those celebrating a special occasion or simply seeking a top-tier steak.

Rare Steakhouse offers a contemporary take on the classic steakhouse, featuring a sleek design and an impressive menu. Their commitment to quality ingredients and precise preparation shines through in every dish. Enjoy a vibrant atmosphere alongside expertly cooked steaks.

Despite its smaller review count, One Prime Steakhouse is a noteworthy contender for those seeking an intimate and high-quality steak experience. This establishment focuses on delivering exceptional steaks in a refined setting. It's a perfect spot for a more personal and upscale culinary adventure.

* This business has a high rating but fewer reviews than average. We include it as a "Hidden Gem" worth exploring.