Best Italian Restaurants in Lexington-Fayette (2026 Rankings)

This top-ranked establishment sets the standard for Italian cuisine in Lexington-Fayette. Expect innovative dishes and a sophisticated dining experience that lives up to its stellar reputation. It's the go-to for discerning diners seeking exceptional quality.

A popular choice for delicious pizzas and Italian-inspired fare, PieTana consistently draws a crowd. Their extensive menu and vibrant atmosphere make it perfect for a fun night out with friends or family. Enjoy a taste of Italy with their expertly crafted dishes.

Rosati's Pizza offers a taste of classic Italian comfort food in a welcoming setting. Known for their delicious pizzas and traditional dishes, it's a reliable spot for a satisfying meal. This is a great place for families looking for authentic flavors.

A true hidden gem, Yearling Pizza delivers authentic Italian flavors with a personal touch. This cozy spot is perfect for those seeking a more intimate dining experience away from the crowds. Discover your new favorite pizza in this charming local eatery.

* This business has a high rating but fewer reviews than average. We include it as a "Hidden Gem" worth exploring.

Bella Notte is a long-standing favorite for its romantic ambiance and extensive Italian menu. With a vast number of reviews, it's clear this restaurant offers a consistently enjoyable dining experience. Perfect for special occasions or a classic Italian dinner.

Experience the warmth of Italian hospitality at Giuseppe's Ristorante Italiano. This beloved spot serves up hearty, traditional dishes in a comfortable and inviting atmosphere. It's a go-to for authentic flavors and a genuine Italian dining experience.

Corto Lima offers a modern take on Italian cuisine in a stylish, urban setting. Their creative menu and lively atmosphere make it a popular destination for foodies. Enjoy a unique culinary journey with their inventive dishes.

Part of a well-loved local chain, Smashing Tomato at Hamburg is known for its delicious pizzas and energetic vibe. This location offers a convenient and tasty option for satisfying your Italian cravings. It's a great spot for a quick, flavorful meal.

Another popular Smashing Tomato location, this pizzeria near Fayette Mall serves up fantastic pies and Italian favorites. It provides a consistent and enjoyable experience for diners in the area. Perfect for a relaxed meal with loved ones.

Carrabba's Italian Grill offers a familiar yet satisfying Italian dining experience. Known for its grilled specialties and classic pasta dishes, it's a reliable choice for a good meal. Enjoy a well-rounded menu in a comfortable setting.