Best Italian Restaurants in Lexington-Fayette (2026 Rankings)


Top rated spots for Italian Restaurant
How we rank these businesses
We use public Google Maps data. Businesses with fewer reviews but high ratings are marked asHidden Gemsto give new businesses a fair shot.
Lexington-Fayette boasts a vibrant Italian dining scene, offering everything from authentic trattorias to lively pizzerias. Whether you're craving classic pasta dishes or a Neapolitan-style pie, these top-rated spots are sure to delight your taste buds.
The Obstinate Sons
Vibe: Chic, ModernTL;DR: The undisputed champion.
This top-ranked establishment sets the standard for Italian cuisine in Lexington-Fayette. Expect innovative dishes and a sophisticated dining experience that lives up to its stellar reputation. It's the go-to for discerning diners seeking exceptional quality.
PieTana
Vibe: Lively, CasualA popular choice for delicious pizzas and Italian-inspired fare, PieTana consistently draws a crowd. Their extensive menu and vibrant atmosphere make it perfect for a fun night out with friends or family. Enjoy a taste of Italy with their expertly crafted dishes.
Rosati's Pizza
Vibe: Family-Friendly, CozyRosati's Pizza offers a taste of classic Italian comfort food in a welcoming setting. Known for their delicious pizzas and traditional dishes, it's a reliable spot for a satisfying meal. This is a great place for families looking for authentic flavors.
Yearling Pizza
Vibe: Quaint, LocalTL;DR: Authentic neighborhood gem.
A true hidden gem, Yearling Pizza delivers authentic Italian flavors with a personal touch. This cozy spot is perfect for those seeking a more intimate dining experience away from the crowds. Discover your new favorite pizza in this charming local eatery.
* This business has a high rating but fewer reviews than average. We include it as a "Hidden Gem" worth exploring.
Bella Notte
Vibe: Elegant, RomanticBella Notte is a long-standing favorite for its romantic ambiance and extensive Italian menu. With a vast number of reviews, it's clear this restaurant offers a consistently enjoyable dining experience. Perfect for special occasions or a classic Italian dinner.
Giuseppe's Ristorante Italiano
Vibe: Traditional, WelcomingExperience the warmth of Italian hospitality at Giuseppe's Ristorante Italiano. This beloved spot serves up hearty, traditional dishes in a comfortable and inviting atmosphere. It's a go-to for authentic flavors and a genuine Italian dining experience.
Corto Lima
Vibe: Trendy, IndustrialCorto Lima offers a modern take on Italian cuisine in a stylish, urban setting. Their creative menu and lively atmosphere make it a popular destination for foodies. Enjoy a unique culinary journey with their inventive dishes.
Smashing Tomato Pizzeria at Hamburg
Vibe: Casual, BustlingPart of a well-loved local chain, Smashing Tomato at Hamburg is known for its delicious pizzas and energetic vibe. This location offers a convenient and tasty option for satisfying your Italian cravings. It's a great spot for a quick, flavorful meal.
Smashing Tomato Italian Pizzeria by Fayette Mall
Vibe: Family-Friendly, CasualAnother popular Smashing Tomato location, this pizzeria near Fayette Mall serves up fantastic pies and Italian favorites. It provides a consistent and enjoyable experience for diners in the area. Perfect for a relaxed meal with loved ones.
Carrabba's Italian Grill
Vibe: Upscale Casual, LivelyCarrabba's Italian Grill offers a familiar yet satisfying Italian dining experience. Known for its grilled specialties and classic pasta dishes, it's a reliable choice for a good meal. Enjoy a well-rounded menu in a comfortable setting.
Methodology
Rankings based on Google Maps customer sentiment.
Own a business in Lexington-Fayette?
See how you rank against your competitors and take control of your online reputation.