Best Italian Restaurants in St. Paul (2026 Rankings)

Mama's Pizza stands out as the top choice for authentic Italian pies in St. Paul. With a massive number of glowing reviews and a near-perfect rating, it's clear locals adore their pizzas. Expect a warm, welcoming atmosphere perfect for a relaxed meal.

A long-standing favorite, DeGidio's offers a robust Italian dining experience with a lively bar scene. Their extensive menu features classic dishes prepared with care, ensuring a satisfying meal for every palate. It's the perfect spot for both casual dinners and celebratory gatherings.

Known for its vibrant atmosphere and exceptional pasta, Bar La Grassa is a must-visit for Italian food enthusiasts. The menu boasts an impressive selection of small plates and house-made pastas, perfect for sharing. Come for the food, stay for the energetic ambiance and excellent service.

Casa Mia Restaurant & Bar is a true hidden gem, offering a more intimate Italian dining experience. Despite fewer reviews, its high rating speaks to the quality of its food and service. This charming spot is perfect for a romantic dinner or a quiet evening out.

* This business has a high rating but fewer reviews than average. We include it as a "Hidden Gem" worth exploring.

Cossetta is a St. Paul institution, famous for its expansive Italian market, cafeteria-style dining, and authentic dishes. You can grab everything from fresh pasta to a full lasagna, making it a versatile choice for any craving. The lively atmosphere and vast selection ensure a memorable culinary adventure.

Red Rabbit offers a contemporary take on Italian classics with a focus on fresh, seasonal ingredients. Their pizzas and pastas are highlights, served in a stylish and energetic environment. It's a great destination for a night out with friends or a lively date night.

Lumi Restaurant provides an elegant yet inviting atmosphere for enjoying sophisticated Italian cuisine. Their menu is crafted with attention to detail, featuring both traditional favorites and innovative creations. This spot is ideal for those seeking a refined dining experience.

Andiamo Italian Ristorante offers a warm and classic Italian dining experience, perfect for family dinners and special occasions. The restaurant prides itself on traditional recipes and a friendly, attentive service staff. Enjoy a taste of Italy in a comfortable and familiar setting.

Focusing on artisanal focaccia and other Italian specialties, due focacceria brings a unique offering to the St. Paul dining scene. Their simple yet delicious approach to Italian comfort food is highly praised by patrons. It's a fantastic spot for a quick, flavorful bite or a relaxed meal.

Mario's delivers a hearty and homestyle Italian dining experience that feels like a visit to a friend's home. The menu is filled with comforting classics, prepared with a genuine touch. This restaurant is a beloved neighborhood spot for delicious, no-fuss Italian fare.