Best Italian Restaurants in Winston-Salem (2026 Rankings)

Experience the true taste of Naples at Cugino Forno Clemmons, renowned for its authentic wood-fired pizzas. Each pie is crafted with imported ingredients and baked at incredibly high temperatures for that signature char and chewy crust. It's a no-frills spot where the pizza is the undisputed star.

Spaghetti Park offers a comforting and classic Italian-American dining experience that lives up to its name. Expect generous portions of beloved pasta dishes and a warm, inviting atmosphere perfect for family dinners. This is the place for those seeking familiar favorites done right.

Agni 2 presents a unique culinary fusion, skillfully blending the rich spices of Indian cuisine with the beloved flavors of Italy. Diners can explore an intriguing menu that offers the best of both worlds, creating a distinctive dining adventure. It's an unexpected delight for adventurous palates.

Di Lisio's Italian Restaurant has been a long-standing favorite, serving up traditional Italian fare with a personal touch. Their extensive menu features a wide array of pasta, seafood, and meat dishes, all prepared with care. It's a go-to for consistent quality and a taste of old-school Italian hospitality.

Little Italy Pizza is a beloved neighborhood spot known for its delicious pizzas and classic Italian-American comfort food. The lively atmosphere and generous portions make it a popular choice for both dine-in and takeout. Come here for a satisfying and unpretentious Italian meal.

Betty on Burke offers a refined yet comfortable dining experience, showcasing a menu that artfully blends American comfort food with subtle Italian inspirations. The intimate setting and carefully curated dishes make it a standout choice for a special night out. Discover a local gem that prioritizes quality ingredients and thoughtful preparation.

* This business has a high rating but fewer reviews than average. We include it as a "Hidden Gem" worth exploring.

Another fantastic outpost from Cugino Forno, this Winston-Salem location brings its signature authentic Neapolitan pizzas to a new audience. Expect the same high-quality ingredients and blistering-hot wood-fired ovens that create a truly memorable pizza experience. It's a bustling spot perfect for pizza lovers.

Mamma Mia's Italian Pizzeria is a family-friendly establishment serving up a wide range of classic Italian dishes and pizzas. The welcoming atmosphere and hearty portions make it a reliable choice for a satisfying meal. It's the kind of place where you can enjoy familiar Italian favorites in a relaxed setting.

Villa Grill provides a comfortable and casual setting for enjoying Italian-American classics. Their menu features a variety of pastas, pizzas, and other traditional dishes, catering to a wide range of tastes. It's a solid choice for a relaxed meal with friends or family.

While not exclusively Italian, BLL Rotisserie Factory offers a diverse menu that includes well-executed Italian-inspired dishes alongside their signature rotisserie items. The modern ambiance and focus on quality cooking make it an interesting option for those seeking flavorful meals. Enjoy a unique dining experience with a touch of Italian flair.