Best Pizza Restaurants in St. Paul (2026 Rankings)

Experience the magic of true Neapolitan pizza at El Hornito, where a blazing wood-fired oven creates perfectly blistered crusts. Each pie is crafted with fresh, high-quality ingredients for an unforgettable taste of Italy. This is the top spot for anyone seeking an artisanal pizza experience.

A beloved local institution, Mama's Pizza serves up generous portions of classic pies with a focus on hearty, satisfying flavors. Their extensive menu and consistent quality have made them a go-to for generations of St. Paul residents. Enjoy a taste of tradition with every bite.

Tommie's Pizza is known for its delicious, well-balanced pizzas that hit all the right notes for a classic pizza joint. The friendly atmosphere makes it a perfect spot for a casual dinner or a casual lunch. Come for the pizza, stay for the welcoming vibe.

Discover a hidden gem in Northern Fires Pizza, where innovative toppings meet perfectly cooked crusts from their wood-fired oven. This spot offers a refined pizza experience with a focus on fresh, seasonal ingredients. It's a must-try for adventurous pizza lovers.

More than just pizza, Tono Pizzeria offers a dynamic dining experience with both delicious pizzas and craveable cheesesteaks. Their lively atmosphere and diverse menu cater to a wide range of tastes. It's the ideal place for a fun night out with friends.

Element Wood Fire Pizza delivers an elevated pizza experience with expertly crafted pies emerging from their signature wood-fired oven. They pride themselves on using premium ingredients to create bold and balanced flavors. Enjoy a sophisticated take on your favorite comfort food.

QC Pizza is a local favorite known for its hearty, no-nonsense approach to pizza making. They offer classic combinations and generous toppings that satisfy any craving. This is the place for a reliable and delicious pizza experience.

Parkway Pizza brings a fun, retro vibe to the St. Paul pizza scene, serving up delicious pies with a satisfying crunch. Their commitment to quality ingredients and a vibrant atmosphere makes it a popular destination. Come for the pizza, stay for the good times.

Known for their quick service and authentic Neapolitan-style pizzas, Punch Pizza is a go-to for a delicious and speedy meal. They specialize in thin-crust pizzas cooked to perfection in high-temperature ovens. Enjoy a fresh, flavorful pizza without the wait.

Pizza Novara offers a refined Italian dining experience, specializing in authentic pizzas with a focus on fresh, high-quality ingredients. Their charming atmosphere makes it perfect for a date night or a special occasion. Savor the taste of true Italian craftsmanship.