Top rated spots for Tire Shop
How we rank these businesses
We use public Google Maps data. Businesses with fewer reviews but high ratings are marked asHidden Gemsto give new businesses a fair shot.
Finding a reliable tire shop in Buffalo is crucial for your vehicle's performance and safety. Whether you need new tires, a quick repair, or expert advice, these top-rated businesses have you covered.
TL;DR: The undisputed champion.
Consistently earning a perfect 5-star rating, Extreme Tire & Auto is a top choice for automotive care. They offer a comprehensive range of tire services and auto repairs. Expect exceptional customer service and expert technicians.
Supreme Tires INC. boasts an impressive nearly perfect rating with a substantial number of reviews. This indicates a consistent level of high-quality service. They are a go-to for tire needs in the Buffalo area.
With a high rating and hundreds of reviews, BIG D TIRE SHOP is a well-established name. They likely handle a high volume of customers with efficiency. This shop is a solid choice for a wide array of tire services.
716 Auto & Tire Inc. offers a strong 4.8-star rating with a respectable number of reviews. Their focus on both auto and tire services suggests a well-rounded approach to vehicle maintenance. Customers appreciate their attention to detail.
King Tire is a standout with an excellent rating and an exceptionally high number of reviews. This level of customer loyalty points to consistent quality and service over time. They are a trusted name for all your tire requirements.
Cleve-Hill Auto & Tire Pros has earned a loyal following, evidenced by their high rating and hundreds of reviews. They provide a broad spectrum of auto and tire services. Expect professional care from seasoned experts.
TL;DR: Great value and service.
Despite a smaller review count, Xtreme Tires Inc. achieves an impressive 4.7-star rating. This suggests a dedicated focus on providing excellent tire services to their clientele. They are a hidden gem for those seeking quality and personalized attention.
* This business has a high rating but fewer reviews than average. We include it as a "Hidden Gem" worth exploring.
Monro Auto Service and Tire Centers is a recognized name offering reliable tire and auto services. With a solid rating and numerous reviews, they provide consistent quality. This location is a convenient option for many drivers.
Buffalo Tires (New & Used Tires) offers a great balance of quality and value, as indicated by their strong rating and review count. They cater to a wide range of needs, including both new and used tire options. This is a practical choice for budget-conscious consumers.
Another well-regarded Monro location, this center also maintains a high rating with a significant number of customer reviews. They are known for their dependable auto service and tire expertise. Expect efficient and professional care for your vehicle.
Rankings based on Google Maps customer sentiment.
Share your honest experience and earn real rewards — cash, discounts, or free items at local businesses near you.
See how you rank against competitors and find out what customers really think — before they tell Google.
Run Free Reputation Audit© 2026 Rviewo. All Rights Reserved.