Unclaimed

Mama Carolla's

Italian Restaurant

#2of 8 italian restaurant businesses we track in Indianapolis

R Score

Must-VisitProvisional

Italian RestaurantFine Dining RestaurantFamily RestaurantEuropean RestaurantRestaurantDinnerVegetarianBeerWineCocktailsCoffeeDessertDine-inTakeoutDeliveryReservationsOutdoor SeatingGood for GroupsFamily-friendly

Google

Every point of this score comes from Google so far. It starts to shift as soon as people review this business on Rviewo.

4.7 on Google · 2,805 reviews · recorded September 2026

Ratings and review counts sourced from Google. Rviewo is not affiliated with Google.

Mama Carolla's is an upscale Italian restaurant nestled within a beautiful 1920s Mediterranean-style villa. Guests can enjoy a full bar and a lovely garden setting, perfect for an elegant dining experience.

1031 E 54th St, Indianapolis, IN 46220, USA

(317) 259-9412

mamacarollas.com/

View on Google Maps

Community Reviews

via Rviewo

AI-scored feedback. Reviews from customers who were at the business count more. What are Rviewo Reviews?

No community reviews yet

Be the first to share your experience through a quick AI-guided chat with Quilly.

How Rviewo reviews work

Quilly, our AI assistant, guides you through a short conversation about your experience. Reviews are scored for quality, and ones that fail our trust checks are excluded.

What is the R Score? The R Score is Rviewo's weighted reputation score, not a simple average. Recent reviews count more, detailed reviews count more, and so do reviews from a signed-in or email-confirmed reviewer. Reviews from customers whose device places them at the business count more too, and flagged reviews are excluded. While a business has only a few Rviewo reviews their part of the score is held back, so a handful of early reviews can't swing it. The score also blends in the public Google rating, and Rviewo reviews carry more of it as they arrive. This business has no Rviewo reviews yet, so its score is derived from the Google rating shown above rather than from feedback we collected. How Rviewo reviews work →

Reputation Snapshot

4.7 on Google · 2,805 reviews

#2 of 9 Italian Restaurants tracked in IndianapolisTop 23% in its local category

Mama Carolla's holds a high rating across a substantial review base, a durable reputation position.

Own this profile to protect and grow this standing.

Are you the owner of Mama Carolla's?

Claim your free portal

The Free plan is free forever · No credit card required

Help Mama Carolla's serve you better

Tap any feature you'd like this business to offer. We'll pass it along.